Sin Bin

[ragingbull]

What's your thoughts on sin bin for 2020

 

[PatMustard]

Waste of time. Teams will just run down the clock until the 10 minutes are up, and they’re back to 15 men. Or women.

Stop clock is needed, but that would be too sensible.

 

[JoeH]

Unworkable at club level, especially league games. This is supposed to be implemented at underage games as well with one match official.
Ludicrous

 

[PatMustard]

Unworkable at club level, especially league games. This is supposed to be implemented at underage games as well with one match official.
Ludicrous

Yes but the county game is all that matters to HQ. They don’t care about clubs or underage.

We already seen during its trial, that if a team loses a man, they fake injuries and play keep ball until the 10 minutes are up, and he returns. Is it going to be any different now?

Absolute nonsense that this was passed. They are making a complete balls of the game.

 

[Big Jim]

Yes but the county game is all that matters to HQ. They don’t care about clubs or underage.

We already seen during its trial, that if a team loses a man, they fake injuries and play keep ball until the 10 minutes are up, and he returns. Is it going to be any different now?

Absolute nonsense that this was passed. They are making a complete balls of the game.

I agree with Joe's remark on another thread! Stop tinkering with our game. Just implement what we already have properly!

 

[Armagh_paul]

The referees have a problem implementing the rules as they stand. If anything there should be something like the TMO system used in rugby. Could even have referees explain their decisions like they do in Ice Hockey. I know it would be difficult to implement at club games but with the use of online services similar to Armagh TV, it won't be long until clubs are covered.