All Ireland series

gael_force_orchard

Well-Known Member
Would it be fair to say the losing of an Ulster final, a semi final yesterday, and a semi final today came down to not having a 'failsafe' kickout option when the game came down to the wire.
It's certainly one factor in everything. Add in decision making and not actually going for it. Balance is the key word. For years we were open down the middle, last year I actually felt we had a better balance than this year. For all the talk of we changed tactics because of being open last year, we had a better balance. When Greg Mc Cabe was sent off against Galway we were 2 points down. Had his shoulder been timed perfectly, we were in possession on their 45 with players in space to reduce the deficit to 1. We were on top at that stage and I feel that we would have went on to win the game. For anyone saying we weren't on top at that stage, we had reduced the deficit from 4 to 2 points, and we had started winning alot of turnovers and primary possession. We changed approach this season as a result. I felt we didn't need too. We tend to overcompensate defensively or offensively based on what went wrong the previous season. What we need to do is stick to our own guns and let the opposition worry about us. Anyway.
 

PatMustard

Well-Known Member
You’d have been ok with Ethan being blown up for the same thing then? I’ll answer that for you. No you wouldn’t have.
Whether he would have been ok with seeing Ethan blown up for same is irrelevant. If it was deemed dangerous play (which I believe it was, and Maurice Deegan said so too), then it’s a foul, and a free out.
 

niall1980

Well-Known Member
Whether he would have been ok with seeing Ethan blown up for same is irrelevant. If it was deemed dangerous play (which I believe it was, and Maurice Deegan said so too), then it’s a foul, and a free out.
Maurice Deegan said it was. OK. I take it you agree with every free Deegan gave against us or every foul he didn't blow for us in the past? After all, he said it was either a free or not
 
Last edited:

ragingbull

Well-Known Member
Maurice Deegan said it was. OK. I take it you agree with every free Deegan gave against us or every foul he didn't blow fort us in the past? After all, he said it was either a free or not
Deegan said it was rough play & should have been a yellow you're wrong again
 
Last edited:

PatMustard

Well-Known Member
Maurice Deegan said it was. OK. I take it you agree with every free Deegan gave against us or every foul he didn't blow fort us in the past? After all, he said it was either a free or not
Deegan said it was rough play and a free out, as @ragingbull said. Past games have no relevance to this incident.
 

niall1980

Well-Known Member
So, no point then. That’s that cleared up then.
Not my problem if you don’t understand but I will break it down for you.
You said Deegan said it was rough play and should have been a free out. The point is so what if he did? Do you agree with every decision he has ever made? If not what makes him right this time? After all ,Joe McQuillan, the only person whose opinion matters, thought it was ok at the time.
 

ragingbull

Well-Known Member
You’d have been ok with Ethan being blown up for the same thing then? I’ll answer that for you. No you wouldn’t have.
To say I wouldn't have wanted Ethan blown up for that just cause he plays my club team & county team is ridiculous,it doesn't matter who the player was or team I would have said the same thing it was 100% a foul
 

ragingbull

Well-Known Member
My Irish News Ulster All Stars Team


Odhran Lynch-Derry
Aidan Forker-Armagh
Chrissy McKaigue-Derry
Conor McCluskey-Derry
Conor Doherty-Derry
Padraig McGrogan-Derry
Conor McCarthy-Monaghan
Brendan Rogers-Derry
Conn Kilpatrick-Tyrone
Paul Cassidy-Derry
Micheal Bannigan-Monaghan
Liam Kerr-Down
Darragh Canavan-Tyrone
Shane McGuigan Derry
Andrew Murnin-Armagh
 

Wide ball

Well-Known Member
My Irish News Ulster All Stars Team


Odhran Lynch-Derry
Aidan Forker-Armagh
Chrissy McKaigue-Derry
Conor McCluskey-Derry
Conor Doherty-Derry
Padraig McGrogan-Derry
Conor McCarthy-Monaghan
Brendan Rogers-Derry
Conn Kilpatrick-Tyrone
Paul Cassidy-Derry
Micheal Bannigan-Monaghan
Liam Kerr-Down
Darragh Canavan-Tyrone
Shane McGuigan Derry
Andrew Murnin-Armagh
Agree with alot of this. Maybe occonell at half back
 
Top